Mon–Thu 8AM–4PM • Fri 8AM–1PM • By Appointment

EP SmartQuote+™ EP Project Planner™ (989) 833-1000

Roof Underlayment: Synthetic vs Felt vs Ice and Water Shield

Shingles are the part of a roof you see, but the underlayment beneath them is the backup that keeps water out when wind, ice or a missing shingle lets it in. In Michigan, with heavy snow and ice dams, the right underlayment in the right places matters as much as the shingles. Here’s how the main types compare.

What Is Roof Underlayment?

Underlayment is a water-resistant layer installed directly over the roof decking, before the shingles. It sheds any water that gets under the shingles, protects the decking during installation, and is required by shingle manufacturers for their warranties.

The Three Main Types

Felt (tar paper)SyntheticIce and water shield
MaterialAsphalt-soaked paperWoven polypropylene or polyethyleneSelf-adhering rubberized asphalt membrane
Water resistanceGoodBetterWaterproof; seals around nails
DurabilityTears and wrinkles more easilyStrong and lightweightVery strong
Where it’s usedOlder and budget roofsThe main field of the roofEaves, valleys and other leak-prone areas
CostLowestModerateHighest

Why Ice and Water Shield Matters in Michigan

Ice dams form when snow melts on a warm roof and refreezes at the cold eaves, pushing water up under the shingles. A self-adhering membrane at the eaves and in the valleys seals around nails and stops that water from reaching the decking. Low-pitch roofs drain slowly, so they need it even more. Most roofs can be shingled down to a 3/12 pitch. By code, anything lower is treated as a flat roof and needs rubber or rolled asphalt roofing instead of shingles. Learn more in ice and water shield and ice dam prevention.

Signs Your Underlayment Has Failed

  • Leaks during heavy rain or snow melt, even with intact shingles
  • Stains on the attic roof boards, especially at the eaves
  • Soft or rotted decking found during a repair
  • Ice dam leaks inside the home

How EPHI Builds a Roof

Every EPHI roof replacement is a full tear-off, so the old underlayment comes off and the decking is inspected. Damaged sheets are replaced before anything new goes down. Every EP AsphaltSeries™ package includes:

  • Ice and water shield at the eaves, in the valleys and around skylights
  • Ice and water shield over the entire roof on low-pitch roofs at 3/12, the lowest pitch we can shingle
  • Synthetic underlayment over the rest of the roof

Upgrades to a higher grade of synthetic underlayment and of ice and water shield are available on any package. Ventilation is part of every roof job. Packages run from EP RidgeLine™ (Good), EP StormLine™ (Better) and EP ImpactLine™ (Best) to EP ImpactLine Premier™ (Premier). Every installation is covered by the EP Protection Plan™ for as long as you own the home. Related: roof lifespan, roofing warranties. See our roofing page.

Get Roof Pricing

In a hurry, away on vacation, or not up for a visit? Ask for an EP Aerial Quote™ and we’ll price your roof without coming to your home.

Or price your roof with EP SmartQuote+™, schedule a free estimate, or call (989) 833-1000.

Chris Kress

Chris Kress owns and operates Energy Plus Home Improvements, a Michigan-licensed residential contractor (Builder License #2102209490) serving Central and Mid-Michigan since 1971. EPHI is GAF Master Elite certified, BBB A+ rated and an EPA Lead-Safe (RRP) Certified Firm, and has served 3,000+ homes with roofing, siding, windows, doors, gutters, insulation, crawlspace, deck, bathroom and stone projects.

Frequently Asked Questions

Got questions? We’ve got answers. If you don’t see what you’re looking for, give us a call at (989) 833-1000.

It's a water-resistant layer under the shingles that sheds any water that gets past them and protects the decking.

Still have questions? We’d love to hear from you.

Ready to Get Started?
Free consultation • Licensed & Insured • EP Protection Plan™